States of Jersey Electoral Reform Models

P.133/2016 Amd 1 Amd

Composition and Election of the States Assembly Amd 1 Amd
by Philip Ozouf

Constitution:

Senators: 6
Constables: 12
Deputies: 26
Total: 44

> Proposition PDF

Withdrawn

Duplicate of:

Representation Data:

Deputies Per District

Constituency	Population	Deputies	Average Representation	Difference from Average	Weighting to Average
District 1 St Helier North	18270	5	3654	-11.05%	1.12
District 2 St Helier South	18270	5	3654	-11.05%	1.12
District 3 Grouville / St Clement / St Martin	19550	4	4888	18.99%	0.84
District 4 St Saviour / Trinity	18250	4	4563	11.08%	0.90
District 5 St John / St Lawrence / St Mary / St Ouen	15470	4	3868	-5.84%	1.06
District 6 St Brelade / St Peter	16990	4	4248	3.41%	0.97
	106800	26	4108

Range:

Most over-represented: District 1 : St Helier North, -11.05%
Most under-represented: District 3 : Grouville / St Clement / St Martin, 18.99%
Number of representatives per citizen: 4 — 5

District Representatives Proportionally

Constituency	Population	Ds & Cs	Average Representation	Difference from Average	Weighting to Average
District 1 St Helier North	18270	5.5	3322	18.18%	0.85
District 2 St Helier South	18270	5.5	3322	18.18%	0.85
District 3 Grouville / St Clement / St Martin	19550	7	2793	-0.64%	1.01
District 4 St Saviour / Trinity	18250	6	3042	8.22%	0.92
District 5 St John / St Lawrence / St Mary / St Ouen	15470	8	1934	-31.20%	1.45
District 6 St Brelade / St Peter	16990	6	2832	0.75%	0.99
	106800	38	2811

Range:

Most over-represented: District 5 : St John / St Lawrence / St Mary / St Ouen, -31.20%
Most under-represented: District 1 : St Helier North, 18.18%
Number of representatives per citizen: 5.5 — 8

District Representation

Constituency	Population	Ds & Cs	Average Representation	Difference from Average	Weighting to Average
District 1 St Helier North	18270	6	3045	8.32%	0.92
District 2 St Helier South	18270	6	3045	8.32%	0.92
District 3 Grouville / St Clement / St Martin	19550	5	3910	39.10%	0.72
District 4 St Saviour / Trinity	18250	5	3650	29.85%	0.77
District 5 St John / St Lawrence / St Mary / St Ouen	15470	5	3094	10.07%	0.91
District 6 St Brelade / St Peter	16990	5	3398	20.88%	0.83
	106800	38	2811

Range:

Most over-represented: District 1 : St Helier North, 8.32%
Most under-represented: District 3 : Grouville / St Clement / St Martin, 39.10%
Number of representatives per citizen: 5 — 6

Parish Representatives

Constituency	Population	Ds & Cs	Average Representation	Difference from Average	Weighting to Average
Grouville	5320	5	1064	-62.15%	2.64
St Brelade	11540	5	2308	-17.89%	1.22
St Clement	10060	5	2012	-28.42%	1.40
St Helier	36540	11	3322	18.18%	0.85
St John	3180	5	636	-77.37%	4.42
St Lawrence	5850	5	1170	-58.38%	2.40
St Martin	4170	5	834	-70.33%	3.37
St Mary	1990	5	398	-85.84%	7.06
St Ouen	4450	5	890	-68.34%	3.16
St Peter	5450	5	1090	-61.22%	2.58
St Saviour	14820	5	2964	5.44%	0.95
Trinity	3430	5	686	-75.60%	4.10
	106800	38	2811

Range:

Most over-represented: St Mary, -85.84%
Most under-represented: St Helier, 18.18%
Number of representatives per citizen: 5 — 11

Electoral Models:

	Districts	Members			Range of Difference from Average
Model		D	C	S	Deputies Only	District Proportionally	District Representation	Parish Representatives
Current Model	17	29	12	8	-46% — 48%	-62% — 42%	-62% — 29%	-62% — 29%
P.17/2021 Amd 2	9	28	12	8	-14% — 24%	-26% — 40%	-6% — 19%	-81% — 24%
- P.17/2021 Amd 2 Amd	9	31	12	8	-10% — 15%	-28% — 32%	-4% — 20%	-80% — 23%
P.139/2020	9	37	12	0	-13% — 10%	-22% — 32%	-8% — 15%	-82% — 20%
- P.139/2020 Amd 1	9	52	0	0	-8% — 7%	-8% — 7%	-8% — 7%	-84% — 5%
- P.139/2020 Amd 2	14	49	0	0	-54% — 25%	-54% — 25%	-54% — 25%	-54% — 20%
- P.139/2020 Amd 5 *⁴	6	28	12	8	-20% — 41%	-32% — 19%	-2% — 61%	-85% — 11%
- P.139/2020 Amd 6	9	37	12	0	-24% — 106%	-13% — 13%	-17% — 82%	-70% — 6%
- P.139/2020 Amd 7	17	33	12	8	-39% — 68%	-58% — 27%	-58% — 15%	-58% — 18%
P.7/2020 *⁵	9	37	12	0	-18% — 14%	-27% — 39%	-13% — 21%	-82% — 29%
- P.7/2020 Amd 1	9	34	12	0	-21% — 99%	-18% — 9%	-13% — 79%	-71% — 6%
- P.7/2020 Amd 2	9	40	12	0	-18% — 17%	-23% — 20%	-11% — 21%	-81% — 20%
P.126/2019	9	46	0	0	-18% — 13%	-18% — 13%	-18% — 13%	-83% — 6%
- P.126/2019 Amd 1 *⁵	9	37	12	0	-18% — 14%	-27% — 39%	-13% — 21%	-82% — 29%
P.133/2016 *¹	6	32	12	0	-9% — 17%	-29% — 16%	6% — 34%	-86% — 16%
- P.133/2016 Amd 1	6	20	12	6	-15% — 22%	-34% — 22%	9% — 46%	-85% — 22%
- P.133/2016 Amd 1 Amd *³	6	26	12	6	-11% — 19%	-31% — 18%	8% — 39%	-86% — 18%
- P.133/2016 Amd 2 *⁴	6	28	12	8	-20% — 41%	-32% — 19%	-2% — 61%	-85% — 11%
- P.133/2016 Amd 4	6	26	12	8	-11% — 19%	-31% — 18%	8% — 39%	-86% — 18%
P.117/2013	7	28	12	7	-28% — 28%	-28% — 14%	-18% — 46%	-85% — 11%
P.116/2013	17	29	12	6	-35% — ???	-24% — 32%	-32% — 32%	-24% — 32%
P.98/2013	12	49	0	0	-27% — 25%	-27% — 25%	-27% — 25%	-27% — 25%
P.94/2013	6	34	12	0	-17% — 24%	-26% — 12%	-2% — 40%	-86% — 6%
- P.94/2013 Amd 1 *²	6	27	12	6	-23% — 30%	-19% — 11%	-5% — 43%	-82% — 8%
- P.94/2013 Amd 1 Amd *³	6	26	12	6	-11% — 19%	-31% — 18%	8% — 39%	-86% — 18%
- P.94/2013 Amd 2	5	35	12	0	insufficient population data
P.93/2013 *¹	6	32	12	0	-9% — 17%	-29% — 16%	6% — 34%	-86% — 16%
- P.93/2013 Amd 1 *²	6	27	12	6	-23% — 30%	-19% — 11%	-5% — 43%	-82% — 8%
- P.93/2013 Amd 1 Amd *³	6	26	12	6	-11% — 19%	-31% — 18%	8% — 39%	-86% — 18%
- P.93/2013 Amd 2	4	32	12	0	insufficient population data
- P.93/2013 Amd 3	17	31	12	8	-42% — 58%	-60% — 32%	-60% — 10%	-60% — 23%
P.2/2011	5	21	12	8	-7% — 11%	-35% — 41%	17% — 41%	-88% — 41%
- P.2/2011 Amd 1	5	21	12	8	-17% — 20%	-35% — 61%	5% — 61%	-88% — 61%
- P.2/2011 Amd 2	5	21	12	8	-28% — 272%	-5% — 5%	3% — 192%	-74% — 3%
- P.2/2011 Amd 3	17	28	12	8	-48% — 53%	-63% — 39%	-63% — 26%	-63% — 26%
P.72/2009	6	37	12	0	-11% — 9%	-21% — 29%	1% — 24%	-87% — 29%
- P.72/2009 Amd 1	6	49	0	0	no model provided
- P.72/2009 Amd 2	12	49	0	0	no model provided
- P.72/2009 Amd 2 Amd	12	47	0	0	-56% — 20%	-56% — 20%	-56% — 20%	-56% — 20%
- P.72/2009 Amd 3	6	35	12	0	no model provided
- P.72/2009 Amd 4	6	37	0	12	no model provided
P.75/2007	6	36	12	0	no model provided
- P.75/2007 Amd 1	12	36	12	0	no model provided
- P.75/2007 Amd 3	6	48	0	0	no model provided
P.64/2007	12	0	12	35	n/a	-78% — 311%	-78% — 311%	-78% — 311%
P.145/2006 Amd 1	12	37	0	12	-31% — 19%	-31% — 19%	-31% — 19%	-31% — 19%
P.151/2004	6	47	0	0	-7% — 4%	-7% — 4%	-7% — 4%	-89% — 0%
P.115/2004	12	42	0	0	-61% — 20%	-61% — 20%	-61% — 20%	-61% — 20%
P.179/2001	17	53	0	0	no model provided
Clothier 42	12	42	0	0	-22% — 35%	-22% — 35%	-22% — 35%	-22% — 35%
Clothier 44	12	44	0	0	-35% — 20%	-35% — 20%	-35% — 20%	-35% — 20%

*^# = Duplicate electoral models

< Introduction